What happens when my no buy ends?
& a reminder not to put anyone (including me) on a pedestal
When it came to starting my own 365 day no buy wardrobe challenge, it was always born out of curiosity. I wanted to put my own wardrobe to the test and reconnect with my creativity. I merely wanted to share my findings in the hope that it could be helpful for anyone else who wanted to try it and it’s the main reason I started this substack. This challenge was never about being a martyr or trying to make out I am somehow better than those that shop. I am not anti shopping.
What I find fascinating is the discourse around women shopping and what they spend their money on has now become a hot topic as a way to pedestal certain people over others. Generally speaking, those that spend a lot of money on clothes etc are seen as bad, those who don’t shop these items are seen as morally superior, and i’m just not here for that. It reeks of patriarchy.
There’s also this strange expectation for women to explain themselves if they do spend a lot of money on clothing, as if they owe the internet or the world at large an explanation, better still a justification. What irks me more than anything is we don’t ask this of men, so why do we expect it of women?
It makes so much sense why people fear failing at a no buy challenge when the moral high ground is only reserved for those who succeed at not shopping. I don’t know who needs to hear this but my no buy was, and still is for me. I’m not trying to prove i’m better than anyone. I am a flawed human being just like the rest of us, and it doesn’t help me, or anyone else, to be put on a pedestal. I have loved this challenge so much because I did it for me. It did exactly what I hoped it would, it has reignited my creativity and my connection to play. It has reminded me to romanticize what I do have, and helped me question my relationship to shopping, but that doesn’t make me anti shopping.
When my no buy ends I have no idea what I will feel, how I will act. I’ve thought about extending my no buy because it’s been so much fun but i’m also wildly curious to see how does it feels to be able to shop again? My hope is that this challenge has given me the tools I need to become a more intentional shopper. Before the challenge, my spending was getting a little out of sorts. Shopping had become a coping mechanism justified by my genuine love of personal style. Needing a little treat every time I had an uncomfortable feeling was not helping my bank balance, or my sanity. I had a lot of stuff, but I felt overwhelmed, uninspired and over stimulated.
I spent my twenties in a lot of debt while I tried to navigate becoming a makeup artist living in London. So when I did start making what to me felt like a considerable amount of money, a big part of me made up for past me who couldn’t afford those things. But if i’m really honest with myself, what I know to be true is that no matter what I earnt (even when it was very little) I still shopped impulsively and sometimes compulsively. I had never let myself sit with the discomfort of not ‘soothing’ myself with a little treat. The only difference is that as I earnt more money, the treats became more expensive.
In the words of David Beckham, ‘I like nice things’, and i’m never going to apologize for that. But what my no buy has helped me sit with is not needing to act on impulse. It’s helped me turn to what I do have first and just take a beat. It slowed me down and has shown me how to feel enough without buying more to fill a hole that shopping alone can’t fill.
Maybe I will allow myself one item a month? Maybe I will do a no buy every other year? It’s hard to make decisions when I just feel so at ease with where my wardrobe currently is, and all I know is that has been down to not shopping for a considerable length of time.
There will inevitably come a point where I shop again and my hope is that generally speaking, there will be a little more thought that goes into identifying what genuinely is a gap that makes sense to fill and what isn’t. And look, there have been joy purchases in my wardrobe that I can’t say were planned, they found me in many ways, right time, right place type of situation, that i’m not mad at myself for buying. I’m not a robot. I don’t expect myself to never buy something that isn’t planned again, but i’m not seeking perfection. I’m just looking to improve the relationship I have with myself and turn to what I do have first. My priority is my creativity, not getting a gold star because I didn’t shop.
All I do know is I want to help more people navigate their own no buy in a bid to reconnect to their creativity, and really explore what personal style means to them. This year has been challenging for many reasons, but (in addition to getting professional help) navigating my way out of depression was helped hugely by my love of personal style. Getting dressed gave me something, it helped me come home to myself.
How we spend our money and on what isn’t anyone’s business but our own. Some of my favorite memories are related to specific shopping trips and i’m not going to apologize for that. The power for me came in recognising the difference of needing something in a bid to feel like I fit in, to feel enough, vs shopping to feel at home in my body. A question that helps me shop with intention is ‘would I still like this item if it wasn’t trending/ if it wasn’t an item that the fashion industry/ creators I love are telling me is cool? If the answer is yes, I would still love it, then I’ve learned to trust my gut.
I’m not afraid to look dated, or out of fashion. I wear what I like, for me. My no buy solidified that belief and turned it into a key wardrobe value, a closet compass if you will. For that, i’m eternally grateful.
Of course in a perfect world no one would judge each other and we’d all live happily ever after, alas it isn’t a perfect world. But wouldn’t it be lovely if we could stop building each other up, just to tear each other down? That Barbie monologue comes to mind.
Anyway, I hope you’re having a wonderful week and thanks for reading.
Harry x
Hi Harry, I’m really enjoying following your journey and your thoughts on your 365 no buy project. I’ve found it very refreshing and genuinely interesting to read about clothes and getting dressed without being pushed links to buy etc. ( see my final point)
For me I’m really interested in how to enjoy clothes without feeling guilty about contributing to the horrendous waste, over production, landfill, poor labour conditions etc. This isn’t trying to make anyone feel guilty but we can’t just ignore it either!
I think the important thing is to find ways of reducing one’s impact in the way that works for you- that leans into your own values/interests/approaches.
There are 3 adult females in my household. We all love clothes. We are all seriously concerned about climate change, the environment and our impact.
But we like shopping too!
And we each approach it differently.
One of us has absolutely masses of clothes and loves buying them. She loves shopping. But they are all secondhand or thrifted. She can walk into a charity shop and pull out perfect things where I can only see a pile of stressful jumble.
Her sister buys very little, usually online, mostly new, very carefully considered, - she does deep dive research on sustainability-and - for an average girl - her clothes are very few but fairly expensive.
I have gone for ‘buy 5’, but 10 months in - (excluding underwear)- have only bought 2 brand new items. However I have been leaning into my interests in making. So I have been dyeing a lot of thrifted (Vinted) items, changing up buttons etc which is also fun and if it doesn’t work out not much is lost and something has been learned! Since lockdown I’ve been trying to make more of my own clothes. I find something very mindful and satisfying about making something with my own hands ( also gets you off your phone!). But it’s not for everyone.
My point is that there are a lot of ways to consider one’s approach to buying, making and wearing clothes but the crucial thing is- as you say- is to be intentional . None of our approaches is morally superior to the other.
I do agree that a lot of discourse around this smacks of the patriarchy but it is true too that women are the biggest consumers in this space and we could therefore make a difference in challenging the mindless consumerism we are fed ( affiliate links and content creators I’m looking at you!) and do our own, personal , individual and intentional thing.
Thanks for all your sharing- I always look forward to reading 😊
This is exactly how I feel as I’m ending month 10 of my no-buy year written so beautifully with no judgement or pedestals thank you!!